| The
process of moving from clinical work to the less structured world of research
can be confusing and a little daunting.
In a series
of articles we hope to make your venture into research both less confusing
and less daunting. In this, the first of the series, we outline the reasons
for and benefits of doing research, and then give some suggestions on
finding a suitable project.
Why
do research?
- It
benefits society. It would be stating the obvious that
research benefits society in general, and the altruism underlying this
reason may be the last one many of us embark on research, whether in
medicine or pure science. Nevertheless, it is worth mentioning that
research, whether basic or applied, is the most important means of adding
to our knowledge of ageing, disease and the individual. Consequently,
if you do good quality research you will have a real influence on clinical
practice - even if this influence seems several steps down the line.
Additionally, as a research-trained clinician, you have the opportunity
to make sure that ongoing research is useful and relevant to the care
of older people.
- Personal
development. Less altruistic and closer to most hearts,
doing research can be intensely satisfying. It provides the opportunity
to become an expert in your subject and for some this is the start of
a lifetime’s special interest. You also develop several general
skills: public speaking, scientific writing, a deeper understanding
of research methodology and statistics, running projects, organisation,
computer literacy, evaluation of published papers and presentations
at research meetings, and the knowledge to supervise or give advice
to junior colleagues interested in research. All of these skills are
fundamental to whatever consultant job you end up doing.
- Another
plus is that taking an extended break from day to day clinical work
allows you to stand back and look at medicine from a different
perspective. Part of this comes through working with
non-clinical scientists and technicians, as well as senior academic
clinicians.
- Finally,
knowing that you have made a contribution to your area is tremendously
fulfilling, and many
researchers find that publishing in journals read by their peers worldwide
is quite a thrill!
Career
benefits
An MD or PhD is very important, even essential, if you want to be a clinical
academic. However, publications and/or an MD or PhD thesis undoubtedly
help in competing for all posts, particularly in centres active in teaching
and research. This is not just because you have specialised knowledge
but also because completing a research degree or publishing papers demonstrates
that you have multiple transferable skills, as well as no small amount
of tenacity.
Finding
a project
Geriatric medicine involves all organ systems in the context of ageing
and disease. Geriatricians also have a strong interest in improving the
quality of health care of older people. Therefore, the research possibilities
in our specialty are unusually diverse, from lab-based molecular biology
projects to health services research. Because of this, collaborations
with researchers from other medical specialties are common.
There are
several routes to setting up a project. Often trainees are offered a research
opportunity by a senior colleague who has a project in mind. Otherwise,
with some ideas of the kind of research you might like to do, you need
to find someone with research experience in your desired field to speak
to about it. If there is no one available locally, perhaps a senior colleague
has contacts elsewhere. You could also make contact with key researchers,
perhaps at a BGS scientific meeting. A Medline survey can reveal researchers
active in your field: virtually all would be delighted to hear from those
who share their interest.
Once contact
with a potential supervisor has been made, think through the following
key components of a successful period of research before committing yourself:
(1) The project:
this should fit with your areas of clinical and scientific interest and
also the kind of research you think you’ll enjoy doing. For example,
you might prefer
patient-based investigation to lab work. You should also think about the
final outcomes
of the project. By definition any scientific investigation involves uncertainty,
but some
projects are heavily based on methodologies which are not properly developed.
In our
opinion, inexperienced researchers should aim for a project which will
yield interpretable results (negative or positive).
(2) The supervisor:
this should be someone who has an established track record of
successful publications in respected journals (check on Medline) and grant
applications.
Your supervisor should also have a good reputation with research students
- speak
informally to as many researchers as possible – and should be someone
with whom you
will get on.
(3) The institution:
aim for a centre with an established track record and with the
infrastructure to support your work.
Funding
Next, you and your supervisor (usually with other collaborators) would
probably need to write a grant application to provide your salary and
other research expenses. Funders include the Medical Research Council,
the Wellcome Trust, Research into Ageing, the Alzheimer’s Research
Trust, and the British Heart Foundation. Virtually all require the applicant
to have passed the MRCP or equivalent, but a training number is not necessary.
You need to think ahead: writing the application takes weeks, and funders
take months to reach a decision. Therefore, the application should be
submitted about a year before your intended period of research. Overall,
it’s a painstaking process but it’s a wonderful feeling when
you receive the award letter.
Please feel
free to email us if you wish to make any comments or ask any questions
about the issues raised in this article. Future instalments will cover
starting your period of research, and all the stages that follow.
Alasdair
MacLullich
Lecturer, University of Edinburgh
a.maclullich@ed.ac.uk
Miles Witham
Lecturer, University of Dundee
m.witham@dundee.ac.uk
|