|
|
This
year’s Spring conference was held in the hospitable city of
Derry. While members from all over Ireland were prominent, there
was representation from all corners of the UK, and even the occasional
Antipodean.
Many
delegates commented that this was an exceptionally well-run meeting,
with none of the usual conference glitches. This had much to do
with the gentle but firm time-keeping, whereby each speaker was
ensured their full slot, and delegates were administered their caffeine
fix on time to maintain everyone’s equanimity!
Opening
Address
The President, Bob Stout, opened proceedings in the splendid and
restored Victorian St Columb’s theatre on Thursday morning,
with an insightful overview for visitors to Derry, on recent Northern
Ireland history and the evolution of geriatric medicine on the whole
island. Prof Stout’s memorable and often poignant address
reminded those of us from outside Ireland of some of the challenges
facing the Irish medical profession during the Troubles.
Renal
Medicine
A series of three complementary talks on renal medicine took us
through epidemiology, detection and management of renal disease,
and dialysis. Dr Peter Maxwell, Consultant Nephrologist
in the Belfast City Hospital, gave us a precise account of just
how much renal disease is expected to emerge over the few decades
– and it is a lot. Geriatricians are well used to dire epidemiological
forecasts, but even some of us baulked at these figures. Dr
Damian Fogarty, Senior Lecturer in Nephrology at Queen’s
University covered methods of detecting renal disease, emphasising
early referral. He went on to guide the audience through the use
of ACE inhibitors in chronic renal disease, emphasising that small
but stable rises in creatinine are acceptable. Dr John Harty
wound up with an entertaining and enlightening overview of dialysis
medicine. He used study evidence to rebut vigorously, myths surrounding
the use of dialysis in older patients. In particular, he highlighted
work demonstrating that dialysis is not associated with a poor quality
of life in older patients; it does not cost more to administer in
older patients; and contrary to what is generally thought, older
people when asked, are not averse to considering long-term dialysis.
|
|
Prize
Winners at the Spring 2004 meeting:
The
Ferguson Anderson Prize awarded to Dr Miles
Witham (Dundee) for the best poster presentation: “Age
is not a significant risk factor of failed trail of beta blocker
therapy in older heart failure patients”
The
Elizabeth Brown Prize
awarded to joint winners *Dr David Craig (Belfast)
for best oral presentation: “The behavioural and psychological
symptoms (BPSD) of Alzheimers’ Disease: Identification of
four symptom clusters”; and Dr Paula Jerrard-Dunne
(London) for best oral presentation entitled: “Ethnic differences
in ischaemic stroke subtypes: the South London ethnicity and stroke
study”
The
John Brockehurst Prize
for best poster on practice innovation, development and audit went
to Dr Paul Diggory for his poster: “Influence
of guidelines on cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) decisions.
Seven audit cycles of CPR”
*We extend a
particular commendation to the medical student, Mr A Mirakhur
who co-authored and presented this paper.
|
| |
|
| |
|
| |
|
Eye
Movements
Friday morning’s programme began with two parallel sessions. In
the Ballroom, Dr Mark Gibson, a consultant neurologist from Belfast, gave
a fascinating talk entitled, “Eye movements: the clinician’s
friend”. Citing lessons from neuroanatomy, engineering, clinical
stories, and movies, he cleared up (some of) the mystique that surrounds
the diagnosis and management of abnormal eye movements. Using clinical
examples and video clips, Dr Gibson reminded us of the importance of the
patient’s history in narrowing the differential diagnosis (and in
avoiding referral through several disciplines), the necessity for a thorough
examination, and the consideration of non-neurological (e.g. thyroid disease,
paraneoplastic) and reversible (myasthaenia, orbital foreign body) causes.
Dr Gibson emphasised the value of photographing and videoing where possible,
and we certainly benefited from those illustrations.
The platform
presentations covered a range of topics including predictors of diastolic
dysfunction, quality of life and screening in heart failure, genetics
and mortality, treatment of carotid sinus syndrome, and smoking cessation
advice. The talks also demonstrated a wide variety of study designs and
populations, from prospective randomised controlled trial in ten patients,
to cross-sectional studies of several hundred! All papers prompted active
discussion in the packed Ballroom.
Myeloproliferative
Disorders
The other morning meeting began with Dr Mary Mullin’s
“Myeloproliferative Disorders - a Problem in Old Age”. This
lecture provided a clinically useful review of the management of common
presentations of haematology problems in older age. It was particularly
interesting to hear how advances in pharmacology are revolutionising treatment,
for example in the use of imatinib (Glivac) in chronic myeloid leukaemia.
There followed
a selection of papers from Manchester, Belfast, Galway, London and Cardiff.
Topics included physiotherapy approaches; spirometry issues in airways
disease; growth hormone and/or testosterone on body composition and physical
performance; issues on breaking bad news; delirium in emergency medical
admissions, contrasting community versus hospital acquired; and the use
of chair and bed sensors to prevent falls in hospital.
Developing
geriatric medicine in the USA
In the first of three excellent guest lectures we were treated to the
fascinating and thought-provoking story of Prof William R Hazzard’s
seminal contribution to the growth of geriatric medicine and gerontology
in the USA. Prof Hazzard’s main strategy has been to focus on strengthening
academic geriatric medicine, thereby increasing professional respect and
attracting more doctors to the specialty: “Research is central to
academic values and power; shun it at your peril.” The massive funding
for Alzheimer’s Disease research in the USA has been, and remains,
an important means of attracting academic physicians to geriatric medicine.
Prof Hazzard also discussed the differences in clinical geriatric medicine
between the UK and the USA. Clinical geriatrics remains a minor specialty
in the USA, in marked contrast to the UK (in which we now form the largest
group of hospital-based physicians). This is certainly more a consequence
of cultural differences but also has much to do with comparatively modest
rates of pay for USA geriatricians, in which consultations for any specialty
are paid at a unit price, regardless of the complexity of the problems
they deal with. It seems that, in the attitudes of many of the broader
medical community at least, there is still a long way to go on both sides
of the Atlantic. Prof Stout has covered this lecture in more depth in
the President’s Column.
Consent,
capacity and human rights
Prof Tony McGleenan, who holds the Chair of Law at the
University of Ulster, imparted a clearly-presented and practical overview
of the legal perspectives on the medical ethics of end-of-life and capacity.
He focused particularly on articles in the European Convention on Human
Rights. Prof McGleenan tied each of the points he was making to familiar
cases, for example that of Dorothy Pretty. Another interesting feature
was the contrast in the differing approaches to applying a legal framework
around the concept of capacity in Scotland, England and Wales, and Northern
Ireland.
Cheyne,
Stokes and Adams
Friday’s midday guest lecture was delivered by Prof Davis
Coakley, who holds the Chair of Medical Gerontology at Trinity
College, Dublin. He spoke to the subject of “Cheyne, Stokes and
Adams, the Men Behind the Eponyms”. Prof Coakley delivered an erudite
historical treatise, which brought us back to the medical Dublin of the
18th and 19th century, beautiful illustrated by historical documents and
publications. The practice of medicine in a bygone era was brought alive
in the lecture and Prof Coakley’s work in the field of geriatrics
and gerontology was acknowledged by the President of the Society at a
dinner later in the evening, when Prof Coakley was presented with the
President’s medal.
Coeliac
disease
In St Columb’s theatre on Friday afternoon Dr Simon Johnston,
a well known expert on coeliac disease, presented a comprehensive survey
of this condition. He emphasised that coeliac disease can present at any
age, is variable in its severity and so is not always clinically apparent,
and that it should always be considered in cases of iron deficiency anaemia.
In the platform
presentations, brave medical student, Mr A Mirakhur described
a large study which used principal components analysis to identify clusters
of variance in the behavioural and psychological symptoms of Alzheimer’s
disease. Another well-powered study highlighted the value of distinguishing
between fluid and crystallised intelligence in relation to white matter
lesions in the brain. Other talks covered the high prevalence of dementia
in Parkinson’s disease, the influence of carriage of the APOE epsilon
4 allele on aggressive behaviour in Alzheimer’s disease, and the
possible role of higher cortisol levels on variations in cognitive ageing.
Colorectal
cancer
The other parallel session on Friday began with a detailed account from
Dr Richard Wilson of various chemo-therapeutic regimes
in colorectal cancer, with the take-home message that the prognosis for
this disorder is better than it used to be, and that we should consider
referring for assessment. Talks on stroke followed, ranging from genetics
to the management of faecal incontinence. On the latter, Dr Danielle
Harari presented an innovative randomised control trial which
demonstrated the value of a single educational nurse encounter in providing
long-term improvements in bowel function in stroke patients.
Sponsored
Symposia
The sponsored symposia included a vigorous debate on the role of geriatricians
in the management of Alzheimer’s disease, a series of talks on the
management of patients with fragility fractures, the growing role of ARBs
in the treatment of hypertension, stroke prevention, and the complexities
of treating Parkinson’s disease in older patients.
Conclusion
Apart from the pleasure of meeting up with old friends and enjoying the
delights of this beautiful part of Northern Ireland, the scientific content
of the meeting demonstrated the impressive range of clinical and scientific
interests in geriatric medicine. Let us hope that with the difficulties
afflicting academic medicine in general, that geriatricians active in
research will persist in producing high quality science which influences
our understanding of ageing and disease, and which will serve to raise
the profile and status of our specialty.
Our thanks
to Northern Ireland’s Spring Meeting committee who worked so hard
to make this meeting the success that it was, and as always, to our conference
organisers, Hampton Medical Conferences.
And so, on
to Harrogate in the Autumn, when the mantle of journalism moves to Wales
while we, the faithful recorders of this, the Derry meeting, relax in
the knowledge that our time is done for another 18 months!
Alasdair
MacLullich, Kevin Kelleher
Susan Shenkin, Brian McGurn ,
and Mark Barber
|