|
At
its parallel session in Derry, the Cerebral Ageing and Mental Health SIG
focused on liaison psychiatry.
Dr
David Anderson, Consultant and Honorary Senior Lecturer in Old
Age Psychiatry in Liverpool, reminded us of the always sobering prevalence
rates for the big three psychiatric comorbidities: depression, dementia,
and delirium. For example, in older patients with hip fracture, delirium
has a prevalence rate of a staggering 70%. This has considerable implications:
delirium is associated with increased mortality, length of stay and hospital-acquired
complications. What is even more concerning is that there is RCT evidence
that relatively simple interventions, such as avoiding dehydration, reduce
the rates of incident delirium, and yet few hospitals have procedures
in place to prevent, detect and treat delirium adequately.
Depression
Detection rates for depression remain low, despite dozens of studies showing
prevalence rates of 10-30% in inpatients, and demonstrating at least 60%
response to antidepressant treatments. As for dementia, Dr Anderson reinforced
the view that hospital admission is particulary hazardous for these patients
and that where possible they should be managed in their home surroundings.
At the end of a bleak (!) portrait of the fate of patients with psychiatric
co-morbidities in medical and surgical wards Dr Anderson summarised the
treatments offered as: drugs only, usually the wrong drugs prescribed,
or the right drugs administered at the wrong times and in the wrong dosages.
Psychiatric
interventions
Dr John Holmes, Senior Lecturer in Liaison Psychiatry
of Old Age at the University of Leeds, began his lecture, ‘Psychiatric
Service Models for General Hospitals’ with a thought-provoking analysis
of the reasons underlying the poor standards of care for older people
with psychiatric co-morbities. Focus-group studies with nurses on non-psychiatric
wards showed that they feel threatened by patients’ aggressive behaviour,
feel inadequately trained, and feel that they are best dealing with other
areas rather than their patients’ psychiatric disorders.
Dr Holmes went on to examine infrastructural and cultural barriers to
providing adequate psychiatric care on medical and surgical wards, for
example the lack of dedicated funding and the lack of understanding among
managers of the benefits of psychiatric interventions. He then outlined
the service he and his team have developed in Leeds; a striking feature
here is his success in persuading his surgical colleagues to part with
waiting list monies to fund better assessment and treatment of patients
with delirium!
Liaison
nursing
Ms Clare Wai, Mental Health Liaison Nurse in Addenbrooke’s,
Cambridge, concluded the meeting with a lecture entitled “Liaison
Mental Health Nursing - An Evalution”. She took us through the history
and development of liaison nursing. The role of such nurses today is not
only to provide a consultation service – though this remains a key
activity, but also clinical supervision, staff support, education and
research. Ms Wai echoed the focus group work described by Dr Holmes, in
that her general nursing colleagues feel that they lack the skills and
the time to deal with psychiatric problems. General nurses are aware of
this deficit though, because the number of referrals to the liaison nursing
service is increasing rapidly every year, and in Ms Wai’s Trust
the referrals are now over 600 per year.
The three talks potently
reinforced the message that the NHS is not doing enough to address the
needs of older patients with psychiatric disorders. However, each speaker
also showed us that, with determination and creativity, much can be done.
After the talks we had a vigorous question and answer session in which
we discussed ways and means of improving services.
The session concluded
with a brief AGM. Duncan Forsyth remains as Chair, with Roger Bullock
replacing John Starr as Secretary, John Holmes replacing David Jolley
as Meetings Secretary, and Jim George replacing Noeleen Devaney as Treasurer.
Alasdair MacLullich remains Trainee Representative.
Alasdair
MacLullich
Lecturer in Geriatric Medicine
University of Edinburgh
|