| BGS
Newsletter Online |
| Harrogate - BGS 2005 Autumn Scientific Meeting |
| Geriatrics is not just the largest specialty in general medicine - there are currently 1,200 consultant geriatricians in the UK - and the fastest growing, it is also, according to a recent survey led by Dr Sally Briggs, the happiest. Certainly the 400 plus BGS members who came to the autumn meeting in Harrogate (our return visit to this fine Yorkshire spa town) had plenty to be happy about. As President Jeremy Playfer said: “Ours is a very lively specialty covering many areas. Some specialties have a silo mentality, ‘long and narrow’, but ours has lots of overlapping borders and this conference has reflected that. It has been a wonderful time for exchanging ideas and there has been a great vitality about the discussions. As well as all the opportunities for continuing professional development, it has also been a great chance to catch up with old friends and make new ones. Geriatricians are very mutually supportive”. As usual, delegates were spoilt for choice among the parallel sessions offered by the scientific programme. It was gratifying to meet up with overseas colleagues from Ireland and the Netherlands, and from as far afield as Iceland, America, New Zealand and Australia. The BGS wishes to encourage more abstract submissions from other countries with a view to providing some interesting “cross pollination”. This story was just one of many in a fascinating look at the history of falls prevention research given by one of the conference’s keynote speakers, Stephen Lord. Prof Lord, an associate professor at the Prince of Wales Medical Research Institute in Sydney Australia, has been identifying risk factors for falls and evaluating prevention strategies for over 20 years. In the Trevor Howell Guest Lecture, intriguingly entitled ‘Horse hairs, smoke paper, pulleys, slide rules and museums’ he paid tribute to some of his predecessors in the field. As well as Galton’s museum and his heirs’ slide rules, a horse hair stylus was used to measure sensitivity to touch and pulleys and smoke paper (where the subject had a lighted candle on his head and the paper showed up the smoke traces) were two ways of measuring sway. There were similarly inventive devices for assessing visual acuity, hand grip, muscle strength and proprioception, all of which have been known to play a part in predisposing someone to fall since the early 19th century. The talk, illustrated with wonderful old diagrams and photographs, was a quirky way of looking at a subject of vital importance: a third of older people in Western societies fall. “Falls costs the Australian health service twice as much as road accidents”, he said, a fact having echoes in the UK. For each statistic there is a human as well as an economic cost in pain, fear, loss of confidence and frequently independence. Prof Lord brought his history of research up to the present day before outlining what he sees as the way forward: greater linkage between assessing the risk factors and intervention. In some cases the risks may be several and require multi-disciplinary approaches. In others they may be relatively straightforward: expediting cataract surgery, for example, or providing strength and balance training through disciplines like Tai Chi. Prof Lord is much intrigued by the fact that old people in South East Asia and Japan have a fall rate half that of the West and may have much to teach us. An intriguing glimpse into the future was provided by Nicholas Robinson of NHS Direct who asked his audience to imagine ‘smart houses’ which could keep an eye on an older person’s wellbeing. “So it would know if someone wasn’t opening their fridge enough or was moving more slowly,” he said. Devices that check blood pressure or pulse are also becoming more wearable and easier to use. “The challenge now is how to use all this information.” An instance of how it is already in use was provided at the same ‘telecare’ session by Sally Herne, who runs a home monitoring system in the East End of London. Under this scheme patients with long term conditions are linked to a nursing station from a user-friendly home computer. “It can ask them how they are each day, it can remind them to take their medication, it can show them the effects of their behaviour such as missing meals. It can also be programmed to trigger an alert if there’s a problem.” Another example of technology being harnessed to serve the elderly was given by Robert Kane, director of Minnesota University’s Centre on Ageing and a man described as ‘one of the great geriatricians of the world.’ In his address ‘How can we improve long term care?’ he outlined an American project where residential care aides were asked to input simple but regular observations on, for example, patients with congestive heart failure. Deviations outside certain parameters would flag up the need for intervention. Not only did the system help the patients, it also made the carers, many of whom were semi-literate or did not have English as a first language, feel much more involved and hence more likely to stay in the job. In the discussion that followed Prof Kane gave a robust defence to the suggestion this was just another version of form filling. “It’s always difficult to recruit people to do this work and we often end up exploiting an immigrant class or family members. We need to make it as meaningful and satisfying as possible.” Where have all the old men gone? He also called for an ‘at risk’ register, similar to that for children, for elderly people with a number of problems and for better co-ordination between primary and specialist care. “Basically geriatricians in hospital need to get out more into the community.,”
According to the experts every older patient should be asked two questions: “Do you have trouble falling asleep or staying asleep? And Are you sleepy in the daytime.” Their answers plus appropriate follow-up questions could help uncover physical and mental health problems quickly. Delegates were also given copies of the Epworth Sleepiness Scale and the Fatigue Severity Scale to help them distinguish between the two states. Tinnitus and Deafness Dr B Ceranic quoted that fifteen per cent of the adult population suffered from tinnitus, the majority of sufferers having organic ear disease, with a small percentage being accounted for with neurological conditions. It is important to recognise that stress, psychological disorders/depression can also produce tinnitus. Exercise – a new consideration Respiratory Medicine Prof Wells from Royal Brompton Hospital and Imperial College discussed interstitial lung disease with special emphasis on chronic fibrosing alveolitis. HRCT and biopsy is needed in establishing diagnosis. However, CT intervention in older patients can be more difficult. The behaviour of the disease is more important than radiopathological changes and mortality is higher in older people. Parkinson’s Disease Pain Management Prof Hanson, President of Danish Geriatrics Society presented a topic of Pain in the Elderly: New Challenges and New Possibilities. Transdermal approach seems to be gaining interest as an alternative option for pain control since NSAID’s and Cox II became disappearing options in the pain management. Professor Hanson stressed that the combination of Tramadol and SSRI should be avoided as this can lead to Serotonin Syndrome. Asymptomatic Carotid Sinus Hypersentivity is more common in the community than previously realised. This topic was presented by Dr Kerr. Dr Lakhani from Leicester highlighted through his presentation the rule of transcranial doppler assisted carotid sinus massage in the diagnosis of carotid sinus hypersensitivity. Dr A Rash, SpR from Sheffield, presented the result of randomised control trial of Warfarin and Aspirin for the prevention of Stroke in octogenarian patients with chronic atrial fibrillation. Adjusted dose of Warfarin was significantly better tolerated with fewer side effects compared to Aspirin 300mgs. Dr Highet, Consultant Dermatologist provided an excellent update on Pomphigoid and its management. High dose steroid still remains the mainstay of treatment for severe disease. Prof R Eastell, whose specialist area is bone metabolism, from the University of Sheffield, outlined the new drug treatment for Osteoporosis including Ibandronate, Strontium Ranelate and Teriparatite. Ibandronate is the latest of this Bisphosphonates, given to a dose of 150mgs once a month. Prof Selby from Manchester Royal Infirmary highlighted the role of vertebroplasty and Kyphoplasty in painful vertebral body fracture. Vertebroplasty and Kyphoplasty have been approved by NICE as long as the centre practising this method has access to spinal surgery. It is only for pain refractory to usual treatment. Dr Selby stressed that appropriate case selection is important, infection such as discitis, osteomyelitis must be excluded by MR Scanning. As well as being a consultant general surgeon at Northwick Park and St. Mark’s Hospital in Harrow, Dr McDonald is also a writer and performer and author of the Oxford Dictionary of Medical Quotations. His wry look at the profession provoked much laughter as well as revealing some interesting facts. The highest doctor’s fee in history, for example, seems to have been a Dr Felix’s operation on Louis XlV’s fistula for which he was rewarded with half of Provence. He’d had to practice on four paupers first though. Liz Gill |